Hilltop Self Storage

2650 Carlisle Pike
New Oxford, PA 17350
59 reviews
E-RENTAL
Rent online, skip the counter and go straight to your space.
We are experiencing high demand and can’t guarantee availability tomorrow. Reserve today with free cancellations.
How It Works with Free Cancellation
1. Reserve a Unit
2. Visit the Facility
3. Decide to Move In
$29.00 - $269.00
Available Units: Show All
30' Parking Space

Vehicles permitted, Drive up

First 3 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $67.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
30' Parking Space

Vehicles permitted, Drive up

First 3 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $67.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
40' Parking Space

Vehicles permitted, Drive up

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $115.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
40' Parking Space

Vehicles permitted, Drive up

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $115.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 5' Unit

Climate controlled, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $29.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 5' Unit

Climate controlled, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $32.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 5' Unit

Climate controlled, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $35.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 5' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $41.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 10' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $44.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 10' Unit

Climate controlled, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $69.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 10' Unit

Climate controlled, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $77.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 10' Unit

Climate controlled, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $83.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

First 2 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $59.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

First 2 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $66.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

First 2 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $71.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Floor 1, Drive up, Outdoor access

First 3 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $79.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Drive up, Outdoor access

First 3 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $79.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Drive up, Outdoor access

First 3 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $88.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Drive up, Outdoor access

First 3 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $95.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Climate controlled, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

First 2 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $109.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Climate controlled, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

First 2 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $122.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Climate controlled, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

First 2 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $131.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 15' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Drive up, Outdoor access

First 2 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $137.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 15' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior, Drive up

First 2 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $153.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 15' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Drive up, Outdoor access

First 2 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $164.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 15' Unit

Climate controlled, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $199.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 15' Unit

Climate controlled, Roll up door, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $223.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 20' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Drive up, Outdoor access

First 3 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $174.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 20' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Drive up, Outdoor access

First 3 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $195.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 20' Unit

Premium unit, Roll up door, Floor 1, Drive up, Outdoor access

First 3 Full Months 50% Off
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $218.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 30' Unit

Roll up door, Floor 1, Drive up, Outdoor access

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $269.00
per month
No CC Required
Reserve
About
Hilltop Self Storage is a Self Storage facility located in Nex Oxford, Pa. We are dedicated to providing top-notch customer service, affordable prices, a secure facility, and a convenient location. We have been proudly serving the New Oxford Community for over 20 years
Features
  • Fenced and lighted
  • Video cameras on site
  • Vehicle requires insurance
  • Electronic gate access
  • Vehicle requires title
  • Handcarts available
  • Moving supplies for sale
  • Email billing available
  • Rent due on 1st of each month
  • Auto-pay available
  • Vehicle must be running
  • Vehicle requires registration
  • Insurance required
  • Homeowners/renters insurance accepted
  • Cash accepted
  • Checks accepted
  • Credit cards accepted (Visa, Mastercard)
  • Allow 18-wheeler dropoff
  • 10% military discount (active-duty, reserves, veterans)
Nearby Storage Facilities
Store It - Willoughby
45 Willoughby Run Road Gettysburg, PA 17325 Gettysburg PA 17325 | 13.10 miles away
View Facility
Prime Storage - Dover
4044 Carlisle Rd Dover, PA 17315 Dover PA 17315 | 13.20 miles away
View Facility
Storage Sense - Dover
2171 Palomino Road Dover, PA 17315 Dover PA 17315 | 13.30 miles away
View Facility
Storage Sense - Dover - Fox Run Road
4411 Fox Run Road Dover, PA 17315 Dover PA 17315 | 14.20 miles away
View Facility

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average Star Rating or Review from previous customers at the Hilltop Self Storage at 2650 Carlisle Pike?
On a scale of 1-5 the Hilltop Self Storage at 2650 Carlisle Pike receives 4.5 out of 5 stars based on 59 reviews.
Does Hilltop Self Storage at 2650 Carlisle Pike offer climate Control Storage?
Yes there are 11 size options for climate control storage units at the Hilltop Self Storage at 2650 Carlisle Pike.
What is the cheapest storage unit option at the Hilltop Self Storage at 2650 Carlisle Pike?
The cheapest storage unit option is $29.00 per month. That is a month to month lease that you can discontinue at any time.
What are the hours the gate is open for access at this facility?
Gate is open Daily 6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Is the Hilltop Self Storage fenced and lighted?
Yes, the facility is fenced and gated.
Are there security cameras on site at Hilltop Self Storage?
Yes, there are security cameras on site.
Are there moving supplies for sale at Hilltop Self Storage?
Yes, there are moving supplies available for sale at Hilltop Self Storage
What type of payments are accepted at Hilltop Self Storage?
Payments that are accepted are cash accepted, checks accepted, credit cards accepted (visa, mastercard).
Are handcarts available to assist with moving at Hilltop Self Storage?
Yes, handcarts are available.
Is there a military discount at Hilltop Self Storage and if so how much?
Yes, there is a 10% military discount (active-duty, reserves, veterans).
Is there an elevator at the Hilltop Self Storage?
No, there isn't an elevator available.
Customer Reviews
4.5 out of 5 stars - based on 59 reviews
Carol Mar 31, 2024

Customer service was great!!

Clean unit easy to get to and I like that they’re open late!

Recommended: Yes

Teah barrett Aug 12, 2023

Amazing

I needed a place to put my household stuff on a quick last moment notice I placed and payed in an hour and got a call in less then an hour thanking me for joining them and asking if they could help me in anyway. My parents have done most of my moving for me but they have told me it has been so easy for them and the place is so clean and nice everyone is willing to help if u need anything.

Recommended: Yes

Kayla Apr 22, 2023

Great

Quick with reservation and leasing paperwork

Recommended: Yes

Michelle Negrete Mar 24, 2023

Great price

I like that it isn't a big price tag like the rest with everything going on and bills going up you can sleep a little easier knowing your not paying so much to try to spare a dollar theses days to keep in storage stuff.

Recommended: Yes

Kelsey Midkiff Mar 13, 2023

Would definitely recommend!!

Great facility and very friendly staff!

Recommended: Yes

Kim Barley Feb 10, 2023

Friendly people and clean storage

Would rent again and recommend this rental place. But was unhappy that I was told prices 3 different times and wrote it down exactly what was told and confirmed it every time. I told them might not rent till week maybe longer. I didn't live close, was widowed with not alot of money and needed to hold off renting till could get help. When I went to pay and reserve unit I was told the price was not for first month rent and that it would be higher. Unhappy and think they should have honored the price.I turned down another unit closer because of the price told here and the friendliness.

Recommended: Yes

Sarah Feb 01, 2023

Very clean and great customer service.

Very great people willing to work with you.

Recommended: Yes

Bob Glover Dec 21, 2022

Wonderful staff, safe convenient storage

I needed a space for a travel trailer. The staff was friendly and efficient. Everything was explained clearly. Price was reasonable. 24/7 access with personal code. Easy and secure access to the facility. Large outdoor storage spaces.

Recommended: Yes

Lima Voll Dec 03, 2022

Absolutely Amazing

The units are very clean. Staff goes above and beyond to help you with the right unit.

Recommended: Yes

SAMANTHA S. Nov 19, 2022

Great Customer Service

I was stuck at home waiting for a package I needed to sign for. I was trying to also arrange for a unit before their office closed Saturday. I was able to reserve a unit and get it setup all online and over the phone. They walked me through everything and honored the pricing as advertised. Kind and knowledgeable staff!

Recommended: Yes

April Ireland Nov 01, 2022

Nice

The lady that set me up was very friendly, And took her time with us, She explained everything to us so it was easy to understand!

Recommended: Yes

Walter Tustin Oct 23, 2022

Friendly and very helpful

Price was very affordable unit very clean

Recommended: Yes

Frank Lewis Oct 16, 2022

Lightning inside and out on old side

Needs better lighting if you’re allowing 24 hour access on the old side

Recommended: Yes

Donna Hildebrand Jul 16, 2022

Excellent customer service

Hilltop has Excellent customer service. Everyone was helpful and friendly and the unit was very nice. There was someone there who was struggling to load their trailer and we pitched in and help them and they were so grateful. The people using the units and that we met were kind and so were the people that rent the units. If you use sparefoot to try to rent one of their units I found you have to insist on using this location. They tried to route me to many other places and I insisted on having a unit here and once they realized I wasn’t going to change my mind they gave me the information. Hilltop is a great place and I highly recommend it!

Recommended: Yes

Danie Kennedy Jun 25, 2022

Yes.5

Good………………………. Thanks thanks thanks thanks thanks

Recommended: Yes

Sonja Williams Mar 09, 2022

I would definitely recommend this facility to anyone I know looking

Excellent I was treated very well. Completely explained everything very patiently. Made things very comfortable for me to make this transaction. N so thankful for the great Discounts... Very much appreciated. Sonja Williams

Recommended: Yes

SM Jan 16, 2022

Very nice facility, great customer service!

Very nice facility, great customer service!

Recommended: Yes

Jessica Nov 09, 2021

Clean and fair cost

The customer service was fast and courteous. The process of renting to moving our belongings in while we are building a house was super easy. The unit is clean and easily accessible. Would recommend to anyone in the area needing a storage unit.

Recommended: Yes

Jeannette Holbrook Sep 26, 2021

Very quick response.

Fast service and was able to get me into a unit that fit my needs

Recommended: Yes

Conor Sep 09, 2021

Excellent experience.

We recently moved to the Gettysburg area and, in the chaos of the move, forgot to secure our storage reservation. Hilltop Storage was able to come through for us same-day at a reasonable rate. The move in was painless, and every representative I interacted with was fantastic. Thank you so much!

Recommended: Yes

Gilbert Aug 13, 2021

Great place

The people in the office are courteous and unloading stuff to the units is easy and efficient because of them being on the ground level; no lifting through stairs or lifts.

Recommended: Yes

Erin Ostrowski Aug 02, 2021

Moving

Awesome place. Highly recommend to anyone wanting a clean facility and helpful customer service.

Recommended: Yes

Kendra Kilgore Jul 26, 2021

Hapoy Customer

I needed a storage unit fast and for a reasonable price. They came through!

Recommended: Yes

Tim Rogers May 13, 2021

All went according to the instructions by representative, thank you

The facility looks great and the compartment locker was clean and easy to get to. We are glad to be able to use the facility.

Recommended: Yes

Donna S Apr 28, 2021

Reservation with office was easy

I have rented at Hilltop in the past. Great experience then, so I chose them now. Great staff, professional & responsive.

Recommended: Yes

Mary Apr 03, 2021

Great customer service

Great customers service, thank you for all your help and quick response to any questions.

Recommended: Yes

Manuel Urquiza Mar 26, 2021

Great service

Great facility and safe, a lot of space to drive between buildings and very clean

Recommended: Yes

Brian J Campbell Jan 30, 2021

Moving and needed a place to start our move.

Great facility. Courteous. Professional. Clean.

Recommended: Yes

Oleksandr Jun 29, 2020

Thanks!

Very clean space, very professional staff. Highly recommend!

Recommended: Yes

Mandy Apr 20, 2020

Great prices

Great pricing, friendly and excellent to work with; would highly recommend.

Recommended: Yes

Margie Apr 14, 2020

I use extra storage for my business-excellent space and good quality care.

Doreen is ALWAYS helpful and knows my business needs. EXCELLENT STORAGE FACILITY-so happy I found it!

Recommended: Yes

Regina Biddle Apr 05, 2020

Very helpful!

Excellent service and very kind to work with.

Recommended: Yes

Janet Mar 10, 2020

Close to where you want to be

A little confusing when we got there because we were on the wrong side of the road, but found our unit easily after we found it.

Recommended: Yes

Dottie Knight Feb 29, 2020

Very nice people in office. Friendly and helpful.

I stopped in to the office on Carlisle street. The ladies were all very friendly and helpful. I enjoyed speaking with them and making arrangements to move my stuff into one of the units.

Recommended: Yes

Kim Aug 26, 2019

This was a good experience.

This was a good experience. This was my first time having to utilize a storage space. The only thing that was difficult was trying to find the storage space. It is in the center of the building. When we went to the office to inquire where it was as a first time user of any type of storage space it would have been more helpful if the person in the office could have taken us to the storage space instead of just giving us directions. Thank you. It is a nice clean unit.

Recommended: Yes

Brent May 08, 2019

Nice and clean

I was impressed by how fresh and clean the facility is. It was easy to find, easy to get started, and looks well-kept. The units are a little close together, so navigating larger vehicles or trailers may be a challenge.

Recommended: Yes

Nehemiah Trostle Jun 19, 2018

Friendly Staff

24 hour access, clean grounds and units. What more could you want?

Recommended: Yes

Petey Brainard III May 16, 2017

Clean, Affordable, would definitely use again

The Hilltop Self Storage facility is clean and expansive while also maintaining a healthy customer service staff that allowed me to feel welcome when storing my things.

Recommended: Yes

Rebecca Apr 21, 2017

Wonderful up to date facility

Beautiful, up to date facility. Easy but secure entry.

Recommended: Yes

Rebecca Apr 19, 2017

Beautiful facilities in an excellent location.

Was impressed by security features.

Recommended: Yes

Toni Oct 27, 2016

They are very flexible

I was quite surprised with their ability to adapt to my needs. I am old and newly single and had to wait on my son in laws to get home from work to help unload my truck. But they understood and just left the contract in the unit and pay over the phone later. So i got everything taken care of in my time. Thank You Girls

Recommended: Yes

Kellie Jul 10, 2016

So far so good! Great customer service

Recommended: Yes

Ryan May 18, 2016

Great experience

Close proximity to school. Clean, and very helpful customer service. Units are great and climate control is available. Would recommend highly.

Recommended: Yes

Jeffrey May 17, 2016

Great staff, great facility

The staff is very warm and friendly, and the price is right. The facility is very clean and secure. Pass code that you create to get in, and you can access your storage area 24/7. Very happy with my choice to use them!

Recommended: Yes

Kristina May 17, 2016

Friendly & Professional

The management of this facility is very friendly and very helpful!

Recommended: Yes

Denise Feb 29, 2016

VERY PLEASED

Everyone was very professional and I was very happy with the clean unit and security. Kudos to the staff!

Recommended: Yes

JP Jan 25, 2016

Great

Not much to say, pretty great all around.

Recommended: Yes

Taylor Nov 08, 2015

Fast, easy, friendly experience

Recommended: Yes

Chris Oct 14, 2015

Recommended: Yes

Shirley Hilbert Aug 28, 2015

Very friendly and courteous.

Very well kept storage facility, and very secure.

Recommended: Yes

Jamie Jul 27, 2015

Great customer service.

Friendly and helpful staff. Would highly recommend.

Recommended: Yes

Lester Jun 24, 2015

Pleasant

Recommended: Yes

stanley gearhart Apr 01, 2015

Every thing was great, the person we meat was very helpful and friendly and the room was very clean

Recommended: Yes

Michele Mar 19, 2015

Great experience! Wanda at the facility was very personable and helpful.

Recommended: Yes

Scott Oct 22, 2013

Recommended: Yes

Debby Musselman Jul 09, 2013

Great experience!

I had no problem at all getting into my storage. I arrived the day I needed to move in, she was expecting me already, had my paperwork ready, and I was on my way in no time.

Recommended: Yes

Virginia Jun 27, 2013

I signed up online and everything was ready when I arrived. The customer service was excellent and my storage unit was very clean. I would definitely recommend to a friend.

Recommended: Yes

Jonathan Nov 27, 2012

Recommended: Yes

doug and faith Mar 21, 2012

love this place

Friendly and very helpful ...we will never go anyplace else again

Recommended: Yes

Powered by SpareFoot