Prime Storage - Farmingdale

2091 New Highway
Farmingdale, NY 11735
30 reviews
E-RENTAL
Rent online, skip the counter and go straight to your space.
We are experiencing high demand and can’t guarantee availability tomorrow. Reserve today with free cancellations.
How It Works with Free Cancellation
1. Reserve a Unit
2. Visit the Facility
3. Decide to Move In
$25.00 - $577.00
Available Units: Show All
20' Parking Space

Vehicles permitted

First Month FREE
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $170.00
per month
$191.00
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 5' Locker

Climate controlled, Floor 2, Interior

First Month FREE
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $25.00
per month
$41.00
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 5' Unit

Climate controlled, Floor 2, Interior

First Month FREE
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $47.00
per month
$79.00
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 5' Unit

Climate controlled, Premium unit, Floor 2, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $55.00
per month
$92.00
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 5' Unit

Climate controlled, Floor 2, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $59.00
per month
$99.00
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 10' Unit

Climate controlled, Floor 2, Interior

First Month FREE
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $77.00
per month
$98.00
No CC Required
Reserve
5' x 10' Unit

Climate controlled, Premium unit, Floor 2, Interior

First Month FREE
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $84.00
per month
$106.00
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Climate controlled, Floor 2, Interior

First Month FREE
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $150.00
per month
$169.00
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Climate controlled, Floor 2, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $176.00
per month
$192.00
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Climate controlled, Premium unit, Floor 1, Interior

First Month FREE
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $183.00
per month
$204.00
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 10' Unit

Climate controlled, Premium unit, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $187.00
per month
$235.00
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 15' Unit

Climate controlled, Floor 2, Interior

First Month FREE
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $200.00
per month
$319.00
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 15' Unit

Climate controlled, Floor 1, Interior

First Month FREE
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $230.00
per month
$335.00
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 15' Unit

Climate controlled, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $267.00
per month
$337.00
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 20' Unit

Climate controlled, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $327.00
per month
$389.00
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 20' Unit

Outdoor access

First Month FREE
Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $459.00
per month
$595.00
No CC Required
Reserve
10' x 25' Unit

Climate controlled, Premium unit, Floor 1, Interior

Due to limited availability, this unit group cannot be booked this far out. Select a closer move-in date to book this unit. $577.00
per month
$606.00
No CC Required
Reserve
About
At Prime Storage, we know your Life Demands Space - and you can find the space you need at Prime in Farmingdale, NY. Our location on New Highway features indoor climate controlled storage and outdoor drive-up access units. Choose from mini storage lockers as an expansion of your personal closet to large units that can fit an entire household's-worth of things or even a car. And speaking of cars, we also have outdoor vehicle storage. Use our 20' parking spaces to store a commercial or seasonal ride. Start your rental today by calling us or visiting our website.
Features
  • 24-hour access (for additional $20.00 per month)
  • Vehicle requires insurance
  • Vehicle requires title
  • Handcarts available
  • Moving supplies for sale
  • Email billing available
  • Rent due on same day each month per lease start
  • Auto-pay available
  • Vehicle must be running
  • Vehicle requires registration
  • Insurance required
  • Homeowners/renters insurance accepted
  • Cash accepted
  • Checks accepted
  • Credit cards accepted (Visa, Mastercard, AMEX, Discover)
Nearby Storage Facilities
GoodFriend Self-Storage - New Hyde Park
119 South 3rd Street New Hyde Park, NY 11040 New Hyde Park NY 11040 | 14.60 miles away
View Facility
Public Storage - Nesconset - 770 Nescons...
770 Nesconset Hwy Nesconset, NY 11767 Nesconset NY 11767 | 14.90 miles away
View Facility
Extra Space Storage - 1034 - Port Washin...
100 South Bayles Avenue Port Washington, NY 11050 Port Washington NY 11050 | 15.00 miles away
View Facility
Safeguard Self Storage - East Rockaway
499 Ocean Avenue East Rockaway, NY 11518 East Rockaway NY 11518 | 15.00 miles away
View Facility

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average Star Rating or Review from previous customers at the Prime Storage - Farmingdale at 2091 New Highway?
On a scale of 1-5 the Prime Storage - Farmingdale at 2091 New Highway receives 4 out of 5 stars based on 30 reviews.
Does Prime Storage - Farmingdale at 2091 New Highway offer climate Control Storage?
Yes there are 15 size options for climate control storage units at the Prime Storage - Farmingdale at 2091 New Highway.
What is the cheapest storage unit option at the Prime Storage - Farmingdale at 2091 New Highway?
The cheapest storage unit option is $25.00 per month. That is a month to month lease that you can discontinue at any time.
What are the hours the gate is open for access at this facility?
Gate is open Daily 6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Is the Prime Storage - Farmingdale fenced and lighted?
No, the facility is not fenced and gated.
Are there security cameras on site at Prime Storage - Farmingdale?
No, there are not security cameras on site.
Are there moving supplies for sale at Prime Storage - Farmingdale?
Yes, there are moving supplies available for sale at Prime Storage - Farmingdale
What type of payments are accepted at Prime Storage - Farmingdale?
Payments that are accepted are cash accepted, checks accepted, credit cards accepted (visa, mastercard, amex, discover).
Are handcarts available to assist with moving at Prime Storage - Farmingdale?
Yes, handcarts are available.
Is there a military discount at Prime Storage - Farmingdale and if so how much?
No.
Is there an elevator at the Prime Storage - Farmingdale?
No, there isn't an elevator available.
Customer Reviews
4 out of 5 stars - based on 30 reviews
Justin Zorn Jan 02, 2024

Thank You

Just rented one month here first month was free it only cost me $29.99

Recommended: Yes

Winonah Dec 03, 2023

Perfect!

The person who helps me is so good of what he is doing. He find a storage that fits my needs in a low price.Sparefoot is a good place to go to find self-storage that fits your budget and needs.

Recommended: Yes

Holly Bailey Jun 24, 2023

Rv Storage

I was looking for a place to store my RV. I called and left a message. I received a phone call back very quickly. I went to the facility. It had exactly what I was looking for. The paperwork was completed quickly and easily, mostly thanks to Venus! She knew exactly what she was doing. No problems. I am happy I found this place.

Recommended: Yes

Chris N. Mar 19, 2023

Excellent Service!

I moved items to a storage locker yesterday. Received a warm, friendly welcome from Venus. She also assisted with guiding me through the facility.

Recommended: Yes

Mark nagawiecki Apr 19, 2022

Easy to get in easy to set up

Handled everything online got access codes and storage units by email helpful staff on location seamless move

Recommended: Yes

Sue Nov 22, 2021

Safe & secure

Very clean, tall ceilings which comes in handy for stacking

Recommended: Yes

Jared Skaferowsky Oct 04, 2021

Overall great

The parking spots are small for all the trucks that are there

Recommended: Yes

Jared Skaferowsky Oct 04, 2021

Overall great

Overall great took a little while to gain access with all the paperwork

Recommended: Yes

TERESA LISSON Jul 24, 2021

quick and efficient.......

I booked the facility for my car and furniture last minute . My booking was mainly handled online and saved me a lot of time with the paperwork. The GM of the facility was very accommodating and competed. All my needs have been meet, I know I have asked for services that are typically not offered and therefore I am extremely grateful .Next time I need a storage unit I wont compare with other locations because i prefer to work with professionals.

Recommended: Yes

Kevin M Gray Jun 21, 2021

love gated security

gated security and building door entrance and exits. Also Temperature Controlled a plus

Recommended: Yes

Knot Satisfied Mar 25, 2021

People are not responsive with any issues, and very dismissive.

The storage facilities had many issues that went on without being addressed for months: the perimeter fence was cut in many places, the entrance key pad didn't work, the doors were left opened, garbage all over the place, they replace the doors of units and didn't show up to do the job on any day scheduled, etc. etc. The people are very unprofessional, rude and dismissive of any issue. They keep raising the rent and don't provide any improvements and/or concessions. I would NOT recommend this place to anybody!

Recommended: No

Lorraine Mar 25, 2021

Beyond despicable customer service and storage unit - disgusting

DO NOT RENT FROM Prime Storage in Farmingdale. They should be shut down. The outside door does not lock so anyone can walk in at any time. There is one elevator in the entire storage facility and IT NEVER WORKS. There are NEVER moving carts or hand trucks so you have to carry everything up and down steps The doors are all different sizes so, your box or furniture might fit in the 1st floor door but when you get to the top of the steps (yes - is said steps because the elevator never works) the door is a different, smaller size, so, your item may not fit through that door and you are stuck in the stairwell with your item. Management is despicable. I was due for a credit and I was told (this is not a joke) that because I was leaving the facility they were no longer giving me my credit because they didn't care anymore since I was no longer going to be a customer. If you leave even one minute past 10pm you are locked IN - NOT JOKING. The gate to leave the facility does NOT OPEN after 10pm from the inside. We were locked in. When we called the Prime Storage support number they didn't know what to do. We were stuck in the parking lot for over an hour and almost had to call the police to get us out. After speaking with other customers I met at the facility they were also moving out because of the same poor management and deplorable conditions of the facility. Prime storage might very well be one of the worst companies I have dealt with in a very long time. I also rent from Lifetime in Hicksville and they are WONDERFUL. Clean, always have carts and courteous staff. My advice to anyone considering Prime Storage in Farmingdale is DON'T DO IT. YOU WILL REGRET IT. You will be carrying your boxes with no hand trucks up and down 2 flights of steps and the management is rude, and does not care about you at all.

Recommended: No

Catherine Civello Mar 24, 2021

I would but, the rent goes up all the time

I’ve been with you guys since August 1, 2020 since then it’s going up twice on me. I feel that if you sign up for a year that shouldn’t go up until the year was up.

Recommended: Yes

Alyce Mar 24, 2021

Overpriced storage

The manager is very nice, the place has improved since the turnover, but it's still too expensive. No elevator for people, few dollies.

Recommended: Yes

Oscar Lopez Mar 24, 2021

Great storage for the price

It would get a 5 star rating but the elevators at this location needs to be updated and fixed. Otherwise I can't complain.

Recommended: Yes

DBP Mar 24, 2021

Fair prices, helpful staff

The staff is helpful and communicative. Facilities are clean and most are climate controlled. Well priced when I compared to area. The only reason I didn't give a 5 rating was due to elevator outage. They are in process of repair so issue doesn't continue.

Recommended: Yes

minch Nov 30, 2020

affordable and good location

it is cheap and good for the price. You won’t regret it if you need a storage really quick

Recommended: Yes

Nicholas Jul 22, 2020

Awesome

Roger was excellent and helped me out the wntire way!

Recommended: Yes

Michael May 25, 2020

Somewhat pricey for a parking spot.

Nice manager in the facility when I arrived. He treated me well.

Recommended: Yes

Anthony Mar 09, 2020

My review

Clean Secure Quiet Climate control is ok, a bit on the cold side

Recommended: Yes

Kinston Feb 13, 2020

Great customer service!

Roger is extremely helpful and professional. Excellent service!

Recommended: Yes

Deborah Bennett Jan 02, 2020

Too Much Stuff!!

Been generally satisfied with storage facility in Farmingdale.

Recommended: Yes

Rob smith Mar 29, 2019

A great value for the space i needed

the facility is still kinda under construction but the facility manager was knowledgeable and helpful as well. thanks roger

Recommended: Yes

Eric D reynolds Feb 17, 2019

Quick move in , friendly manager

The manager on site was very knowledgeable helpful , He took no time at all to help me with my move in . He was able to get me done with paper work in about 10 minutes.

Recommended: Yes

Jessica May 05, 2018

Convienant 24/7 access, carts, freight elevator, bathroom, low price

Was impressed on rental promotion. However, the office computer was freezing up, took a long time to get paperwork complete. Worker had to send documents via Email for e signings. The gate code didn't work the couple times trying it out. The restroom is locked, need to ask for key & is difficult to close & lock door. Needs code entry & there was no tissue or soap.

Recommended: Yes

Dunn Apr 24, 2018

Clean and friendly staff

This facility is very clean with great price. The staff is very friendly and willing to help. I highly recommend this facility to my friends! Very happy customer!

Recommended: Yes

Jeury R Apr 24, 2018

Very Clean, Safe, Friendly Staff

Was on the market for a safe clean well priced storage facility and i am SO GLAD i came across these guys. Sheldon (the manager) was expresmly helpful in order for me to not get something bigger than i needed. Very well pleased would reccomend 10/10.

Recommended: Yes

Adriana Apr 24, 2018

Great

Great price for storage unit and good customer service.

Recommended: Yes

Phil Apr 18, 2018

Great experience

My first time getting a storage and glad I found this place. The staff are great and the prices are hard to beat.

Recommended: Yes

Michael Apr 04, 2018

For the price It’s perfect can’t beat it.

Facility was taken over by prime storage a month. From my experience it was simple. A little old and outdated but the customer service rep Sheldon was really nice and helpful. Heard there gonna do renovations now that there taken over by prime storage cant wait.

Recommended: Yes

Powered by SpareFoot